This was one of my very favorite product reviews I’ve done to date. (Big shocker there!) One of my favorie parts of Thanksgiving is the selection of yummy pies for dessert. This year was especially wonderful when I got to sample different Mrs. Smith’s Signature Deep Dish pies! My family members weren’t complaining about this either.
This year for Thanksgiving I took my husband and two kids to my aunt and uncle’s house in Idaho. We were there with my mom and some of my siblings, as well as grandparents, cousins, aunts, and uncles on my mom’s side. It was a wonderful feast and my aunt and uncle did such a good job and were gracious hosts.
Here comes my confession: The entire time I was eating, all I could think about was how I wanted to try these pies. I was so excited! We baked them at my mom’s house and I’m pretty sure I was drooling. After Thanksgiving dinner we cleaned up and relaxed for a little bit before breaking out the pies. There were eight pies placed on the kitchen counter. We were all in awe, staring at their beauty as we went back and forth in our minds deciding which we would try first.
My family members were excited to see these new pies I had brought for them to try! We sampled the Signature Deep Dish Dutch Apple Pie with Caramel Sauce, Signature Deep Dish Cherry Pie with Butter Fudge Sauce, and Signature Deep Dish Peach Pie with Cream Cheese Icing. And you know I tried each and every one! (The fourth option was Signature Deep Dish Pumpkin Pie with Cream Cheese Icing, but stores were all out everywhere we looked. It must be a popular pie!)
All three of these pies were really something! Each had great flavor and texture, and we all loved the different topping options.
*CLOSED*
_________________________________
**Congratulations, Julie, comment #94! You are the winner of the Williams-Sonoma $50 gift card and Mrs. Smith’s pie! An e-mail has been sent to you.**
- St. Patrick’s Day Caramel Pretzel Bites - February 28, 2026
- Lucky Charms Treats for St. Patrick’s Day - February 25, 2026
- Copycat Cafe Rio Sweet Pork Barbacoa Salads - August 3, 2025
Kayla Marie Hyatt Cameron says
Cherry all the way baby!! Especially if it has chocolate! I’d get the mandolin slicer at Williams Sonoma because mine is getting dull
Parrish Family says
It would be a toss up between peach and pumpkin. As for Williams and Sonoma I have never shopped there but I would love a chance to remedy that.
B Amberson says
Pumpkin pie for sure! I would probably by kitchen utensils from W.S.
bjamberson@yahoo.com
BroncoMom says
Just looking at the picture of all those pies makes my mouth water. The deep dish cheery pie with the butter fudge topping gets my vote. Throw in the gift certificate from Williams – Sonoma to purchase the Baked Brownie pan and a Cupcake Cookbook, you have many this family very happy!
BroncoMom.is.ann@gmail.com
Jennai says
I would choose the Pumpkin Pie with Cream Cheese Icing because it sounds amazing! I would get the Williams-Sonoma Pomegranate Citrus Roasting Glaze, Williams-Sonoma Turkey Gravy Base and the All-Clad Professional Roast Lifters to use with Christmas dinner!
JenniferAnne74 @ aol.com
Jennai says
I follow Mrs. Smith’s on Pinterest – JenniferAnne74
Jennai says
I follow Mrs. Smith’s on Facebook – Jennifer Keefer
JenniferAnne74 @ aol.com
Whisper says
I’d prefer the dutch apple with caramel sauce. I’d use the gift cert. to buy baking dishes. email is whispersanddreams@gmail.com
Whisper says
I follow Mrs. Smith’s on Pinterest.
Whisper says
I liked Mrs Smith’s on Facebook.
Elizabeth Debbon says
Dutch apple pie!! looks soo good. Thank you 🙂 elizabethdebbon7@gmail.com
Elizabeth Debbon says
I liked Mrs. Smith on fb 🙂
Chelsea and Cody says
I would choose the deep dish cherry pie~And Williams sonoma…O how I LOVE that store! Where to begin? I guess right now I would get a baby food blender for my TWIN boys! Thanks!
Julie says
Signature Deep Dish Peach Pie with Cream Cheese Icing
and some spatulas
thanks
aunteegem@yahoo.com
Julie says
mrs. smith pinterest 321gem
aunteegem@yahoo.com
Julie says
like fb Julie Scott Laws
aunteegem@yahoo.com
Parrish Family says
I “liked” Mrs. Smith’s Pies. Now I would “love” to taste it 🙂
Parrish Family says
I “liked” Williams-Sonoma.
Zellers says
I would get a dutch apple pie because it looks AMAZING and because the one I attempted to make for thanksgiving was a total FAIL. It tasted like bland fruit soup, surrounded by soggy pie crust…yuck!
Zellers says
“Liked” Mrs. Smith’s Pies on facebook. The more I think about apple pie, the more I want some now!